Blog
Antivirus Isn't the Question Anymore
For years the cyber-insurance application asked a simple question: is antivirus installed and up to date? Most companies could say yes without thinking about it.
That question is fading. In our review of 13 public carrier applications (November 2026), 9 asked by name about EDR, MDR or XDR. A few older official forms still ask only about antivirus, but the newer ones have moved on, and several want the product name, how much of the company it covers, and who is watching the alerts.
If those letters mean nothing to you, you're in good company. Here's what they mean and why the carriers changed the question.
Antivirus versus EDR, in plain words
Traditional antivirus works mostly like a wanted-poster board. It knows what known bad files look like and blocks them. That still helps, but modern attackers often don't use a known bad file. They log in with a stolen password and use ordinary tools that are already on the computer, so there's nothing on the wanted board to match.
EDR (endpoint detection and response) watches behavior instead. An "endpoint" is just a computer or server. EDR notices when something on a computer starts acting strangely, such as a program suddenly encrypting hundreds of files, or a user account trying to switch off security tools at 2 a.m. It can isolate that computer from the network with one click, or automatically.
MDR (managed detection and response) is EDR plus a team of people, usually at an outside security company, who watch the alerts around the clock and act on them.
XDR (extended detection and response) stretches the same idea beyond computers to email, cloud accounts and the network. For a company our size, the label matters less than the answers below.
Why carriers care about this
Ransomware rarely happens in a single moment. There's usually a stretch, sometimes days, between the first break-in and the encryption. An attacker gets in, looks around, finds the backups and moves between machines. EDR is designed to catch that middle stretch. Antivirus often isn't.
So from the underwriter's chair, "we have antivirus" says you've locked the doors. "We have EDR on every machine, and someone answers the alert at night" says you'd also notice someone walking around inside.
The four questions behind the checkbox
The better applications break this into pieces. At-Bay and Beazley go as far as giving you a list of products to choose from. Read across the forms, and they're asking four things.
1. What exactly is it? The product name. "Microsoft," "the IT company handles it" or "the usual" isn't an answer. Many products have both an antivirus tier and an EDR tier under the same brand, so the exact name matters.
2. How much does it cover? Every workstation and every server, including the important servers that run logins for the whole office. A tool on 80 percent of laptops leaves 20 percent of doors unwatched, and attackers don't need many.
3. Is anyone watching? At-Bay's form offers a checkbox for EDR that is "deployed but not actively monitored." That's an honest answer, but it's a weaker one. An alert that fires at 9 p.m. Friday and is read at 9 a.m. Monday has given an attacker a whole weekend.
4. Can it act on its own? Some tools are set only to alert, while others can automatically isolate a computer that's behaving badly. Ask which mode yours is in.
The awkward conversation with your IT provider
When I ran IT at a company of about 200 people, this was the conversation that most often revealed a gap between what the owner believed and what was actually installed. Nobody was hiding anything. The tool had been bought years earlier, the provider's standard package had changed, a few servers had been left out because the tool slowed something down, and nobody had asked who reads the alerts.
The fix isn't usually dramatic. Often it's an upgrade to a higher tier, an agent pushed to the machines that were skipped, and a decision about who watches after hours: your provider, a dedicated MDR service, or a named internal person with a phone.
What it costs, honestly
EDR and MDR are priced per device or per user per month, and the range is wide. Some bundles already include one. Microsoft 365 Business Premium, for example, includes Microsoft Defender for Business, an EDR tool that is sometimes paid for but never fully deployed. Check what you're already paying for before buying anything new. An MDR service costs more because you're paying for people, but for a company without its own security staff, it's often the only realistic way to have someone watching at night.
The CFO question isn't "is this expensive?" It's "what does a week of downtime cost us, and does this shorten it?" There's more on that budgeting conversation elsewhere in this library.
A word on servers and the "it slows things down" exception
The servers that matter most, such as the ones that handle logins, files and accounting, are exactly the ones attackers aim for. They're also the ones most often excluded from EDR because an install once caused a performance problem. If you find an exception like that, don't accept it as permanent. Modern tools let you tune what they watch. An unprotected central server is the gap a carrier would most want to know about.
What to do Monday morning
- Ask your IT person or provider for the exact product name running on a typical office computer and a typical server, and whether it's EDR or only antivirus.
- Ask what percentage of computers and servers it covers, and get the list of anything excluded, with the reason.
- Ask who receives an alert at 9 p.m. on a Friday and what they're authorized to do about it.
- Check your existing licenses. You may already own an EDR tool that isn't fully turned on.
- Write the four answers down and date them before anyone fills in the renewal form.